Heart theories

[HeavenlyFantasy]

I'm surprised there isn't already a thread about this.

Who do you think has the Heart? I don't think it's Allen or Lenalee, that would be way too predictable.

It would be a nice twist if Lavi turned out to have the Heart, seeing as he's not supposed to be too close to the Innocence. So yeah, that's who I'm guessing it is.

[Niko]

Hmmm like I said it'd be nice if the Earl has it and he causes wars for reasons we don't know yet! XD

Or he has the one half and the other half belongs to Allen or sth!

But I like that concept: Good, Evil, balance! (symmetry)

[HeavenlyFantasy]

Interesting idea, and I like the balance concept too. Plus, it would be a pretty good twist. Much better than just Allen having the Heart.

I still think it's Lavi though.

[Trinny]

I don't think any of the current exorcists has the heart. Hevlaska has examined all of the Innocences in the order, if one of them was the heart, which would be very noticable because of it's supposed great power, the order would already have known.

Maybe any innocence can evolve into the heart if the person compatible with it is highly enough synchronized. That's what makes the most sense to me.

Oh, and just a thought: if God's Crystal was a cube, then how come there are 109 pieces? Though, of course, they cubes doesn't have to have the same size...haha...^^;

[HeavenlyFantasy]

Well the Earl said something about the Heart "hiding itself", so maybe not even Hevlaska can tell which Innocence is the Heart? And it isn't necessarily more powerful than the other Innocence fragments.

The thing about the Heart being hidden points to it being Lavi, as somebody who's supposed to be objective and observe from the outside would seem unlikely to have it... operative word being "seem".

[Trinny]

The Earl also said that the heart has already awakened, and that the person holding the heart is currently in hiding.

[Mina]

it would be nice if it would be lavi who have the heart
but i dont think that lenalee and allen have the heart together,either

i think cross knows who has it

[addenza]

Here's my theory:

1. The owner of the Heart has created a duplicate of the Heart and set it loose in the world to avoid detection by both the Order and the Earl. (Well, literally. You know what I mean, right?) The reason s/he wants to do that is probably because the Earl is well, evil and there's probably something else about the inner workings of the Vatican and the owner of the Heart doesn't want to land the Heart into either side's hands.

2. The Black Order/Hevlaska doesn't know anything about the Heart except that once it's destroyed, all the other innocence fragments will disintegrate. So even if Hevlaska has come into contact with the Heart, she might not know it herself. If the Heart is so noticable, it would have already been taken by either side long ago. The Earl seems to know something else about the Heart. Remember that he said if the owner of the Heart knew about the true purpose of the akuma, it would not be good for him/his side? So the Heart probably has some other powers which the Black Order doesn't know of.

3. What if the Heart has the power to erase the memory of its conformer? So it's something like the Heart manipulating the memories of its conformer. Perhaps the owner is already in the Black Order, but s/he themselves don't know about it and thus can't reveal that they have the Heart.

4. The special case of Lenalee's innocence moving to protect her when she was fighting Eshi was because her feelings resonated with her innocence, and she even would sacrifice her own life using maximum invocation to kill Eshi in order to protect her friends so it wanted to protect her (the will of the innocence).

5. For Allen, I'm not too sure, but I'm thinking it's something along those lines too, using maximum invocation to save Suman. (I still think that Allen's innocence is more spectacular, mending the hole in his heart.) I can't figure out how Allen's innocence would not disappear when it was disintegrated to particles, though. So I'm going with the theory that Allen has the Heart. After all, the Heart can't be destroyed so easily, right? If not, the innocence-wielders would be at a great disadvantage. Besides, did you guys notice that Allen's innocence hand looks like the innocence was forcibly pushed into his hand? As in, before he upgraded to Crown Clown. The previous fourteenth might have found the Heart and forced it into his hands while he transferred his memories into Allen. Remember that in the current arc, Timothy's father had force-fed him the innocence and it actually conformed to him too? So I'm thinking it's something like that.

Yeah, sorry for the long-winded analysis. ><

[Orpheus 2]

Good Theory.

It is also possible that the Heart incarnated itself into a random normal human being with no special powers. Allen's and Lenalee's innocences may be decoy hearts to further throw off the Earl and the Vatican from its location. He may have joined the 14th as a follower in hopes of using his unique powers to defeat the Earl. The Heart may have given a part of itself or created a new innocence and gave it to the 14th. He planned to use the person who the 14th chose to be his successor in order to advance his plans to surely defeat the Earl without another catastrophic end like the Great Flood.

[addenza]

I think that's a plausible theory too(: But I wish that we could know more about the abilities of the Heart...