Heart theories

[Vcenter]

Seem no one, either black order or Noah and Earl can know about it. If heart is the source of all innocences, so its power is split to all . Some how if they destroy the innocences, the heart's power will gain and at the end, we will know it.
I guess Allen is the one who has the heart his power gains rapidly from the begining to now

[addenza]

Heehee, that's a good theory too! Erm, but I just wanted to clarify a few points with you...
So you're saying that the Heart gains power when the fragments of innocences are destroyed and it would be obvious who has the Heart at the end of the series? And then... I agree that Allen has the Heart! ^^

[Orpheus 2]

If the all the Innocences are destroyed when the Heart is destroyed, then it may be possible to create new Innocences using the Heart like how the Akuma Egg creates new Akuma.

[xShatterdWings]

At Times It Lies..Do Not Be Decieved By The 'Heart'

I Honestly think that it's Allen, Yu, Or Lavi. It just makes sense to me...But then again, I don't have the best luck ever so I don't know if I'm right haha. I realy hope it's one of those three. It would be really intersting and entertaining in my opinon...

[addenza]

If the all the Innocences are destroyed when the Heart is destroyed, then it may be possible to create new Innocences using the Heart like how the Akuma Egg creates new Akuma.

I agree with that! It would be quite interesting to see fragments of innocence being recreated!!! And I wonder what can the Heart really do such that the Earl wants to eliminate the guy... Other than destroying all the innocence fragments at one go, I mean... Since the Earl said in one chapter that it would not be beneficial to him if the owner of the Heart found out the real reason behind the akumas...

[Sparkles]

I think the heart is Bookman. Because that would totally be like sods law and stuff.

[KelseyEffingRenee]

I don't think Allen nor Lenalee has the Heart. I just think their Innocence is very
protective over it's Host. Maybe Lavi has it; It would be a twist, but I'm not sure if I would be satisifed with that.
Eh, Cross might have it. But that seems too predictable to me.
But...I am currently talking to someone (another DGM fan) about this same exact thing, and their theory is very interesting;

"Maybe the Heart is in the 14th's piano? It doesn't seem like any of the exorcists have it, and the Earl mentioned something about it 'hiding'...And since the Earl doesn't know of the 14th's room...I don't know. It just kind of seems like it could be there. Since the 14th supposedly betrayed the Noah Clan, maybe he had the Heart, and hid it..Seems kinda plausible to me. And besides, it would be a big twist since everyone is trying to figure out who has the Heart when they should actually be trying to figure out what has the Heart.
And since Mana

SPOILER:

was the 14th's brother

, maybe that's why he 'made-up' that language with Allen, so that Allen could play the piano, because Allen has something to do with the Heart...? Well, that part I'm not very sure about, but yeah. That's why I think anyways."

(By the way, I found out the SPOILER ten minutes earlier from someone else. I guess I'm the only one who doesn't know these things! :P)
I thought his theory was pretty clever, so I did a little of the copy-and-paste-magic just so I could share it with all of you. (:

[addenza]

I don't think Allen nor Lenalee has the Heart. I just think their Innocence is very
protective over it's Host. Maybe Lavi has it; It would be a twist, but I'm not sure if I would be satisifed with that.
Eh, Cross might have it. But that seems too predictable to me.
But...I am currently talking to someone (another DGM fan) about this same exact thing, and their theory is very interesting;

"Maybe the Heart is in the 14th's piano? It doesn't seem like any of the exorcists have it, and the Earl mentioned something about it 'hiding'...And since the Earl doesn't know of the 14th's room...I don't know. It just kind of seems like it could be there. Since the 14th supposedly betrayed the Noah Clan, maybe he had the Heart, and hid it..Seems kinda plausible to me. And besides, it would be a big twist since everyone is trying to figure out who has the Heart when they should actually be trying to figure out what has the Heart.
And since Mana

SPOILER:

was the 14th's brother

, maybe that's why he 'made-up' that language with Allen, so that Allen could play the piano, because Allen has something to do with the Heart...? Well, that part I'm not very sure about, but yeah. That's why I think anyways."

(By the way, I found out the SPOILER ten minutes earlier from someone else. I guess I'm the only one who doesn't know these things! :P)
I thought his theory was pretty clever, so I did a little of the copy-and-paste-magic just so I could share it with all of you. (:

Actually, I don't think it's in the piano, cause the Earl said that the "Heart has definitely awakened". The Heart might be able to think for itself, but without a conformer, it cannot do anything. It can't move on its own unlike humans. Well, that being said, the conformer might not be human, but since it has to evade the capture of the Earl and the Black Order, I'm inclined to think that a human has "awakened" and is using the Heart.

[KelseyEffingRenee]

I personly don't know who could possibly have the Heart. I just thought his theory was pretty unique, since everyone is throwing out names of excorcists and what not while he is thinking that maybe an object instead of a person has it. But then again, from the conversations I've had with him, I've realized he does a lot of thinking outside of the box. :P I haven't read the manga, only watched the anime, so I don't really know enough information to start guessing who or what possesses the Heart. It could be Tim for all we know. (Hahahaha. Wouldn't that just be ironic? ) We'll just have to wait and see, wont we.

But what you said made perfect sense. (:

[addenza]

Anyway, I have new theories (again).
Something that Komui said about the Heart - it is necessary to destroy the Earl. (That's what was in the Chinese manga that I finally bought)
And then... Hevlaska's prediction - Allen's innocence will create a "Destroyer of Time" in the dark future.
Hmm... So Allen could be the Heart? Though if we look at the scanlations, it's probably a whole new story.

And then, about the maximum invocation part. Allen was actually the first for the innocence to possess a will of its own and move to protect him. After that, Lenalee used maximum invocation and her innocence possessed a will of its own too. Well, from that time he resurrected Mana it already had a will of its own... So maybe it could be something like if the innocence fragments were to have any special evolutions (like possessing a will of its own), the Heart must be the one to take the lead?