Mana and The Earl

[hashbrowns576]

so, I'm new, i created an account just to ask this one question/ get opinions on mana and the earl.


while reading the newest chapter, chapter 206 they showed what mana looked like with no make up or clownieness. and that image, though a bad one, looks strikeingly like the earl

heres the earl
D.Gray-Man 187 - Read D.Gray-Man 187 Online - Page 49

and mana
D.Gray-Man 206 - Read D.Gray-Man 206 Online - Page 17

I dont know maybe theres no relation, i know that it should be impossible for them to be the same because the earl brought mana back as an akuma.....

i just want to know people opinions on the two

[fourteenth]

Hi! I read your post so i decide to join here too.

I'm curious about that too..it's ironic if the side view appearance of Mana was coincidentally the same as the Earl. Maybe they have more secrets in their identities that are not yet revealed. :3

[Mikki Walker]

*GASP* Ur right!

I don't think they're the same person. Maybe there was another brother Cross didn't know about. Maybe The Earl took on that human form to fool Neah so he could kill him. Your guess is as good as mine.

[fourteenth]

*GASP* Ur right!

I don't think they're the same person. Maybe there was another brother Cross didn't know about. Maybe The Earl took on that human form to fool Neah so he could kill him. Your guess is as good as mine.

nyah~ your first and second sentence are seems to me that its opposed to third and last sentence you made. do you mean that the Earl was also their brother? or the Earl has take Mana's form to fool Neah? Can you make it clear to me? X)

[Mikki Walker]

Well, they're two different guesses. I'm saying maybe Neah, Mana, and the Earl are all brothers. Then I'm saying (different possibility) that maybe the Earl took on Mana's form to kill Neah while the REAL Mana was somewhere else. I don't think the Earl and Mana are the same person.

Sorry if this makes it worse.

[fourteenth]

Well, they're two different guesses. I'm saying maybe Neah, Mana, and the Earl are all brothers. Then I'm saying (different possibility) that maybe the Earl took on Mana's form to kill Neah while the REAL Mana was somewhere else. I don't think the Earl and Mana are the same person.

Sorry if this makes it worse.

ah? Good theory. :>

can you tell me your whole theory? On how the Earl can be their brother? :3

[Mikki Walker]

I don't have a whole theory. I'm just guessing.

[Kannagi]

My theory of how Allen became the 14th is that Neah wanted to choose some one close to Mana. After Neah died, I doubt Mana ever did have anyone close to him and then one day he "adopts" a son and Neah took advantage of this and filled Allen with his soul and memories. Also people that are saying the innocence looked forced into his arm by someone like Neah couldn't be right because it is clearly stated that Allen was thrown away at birth because of his "defective" arm, so I doubt that's an accurate theory.

For the similarity in looks of the Earl and Mana could be mere coincidence, but I do believe there is some strange story behind the Walker brothers and the earl.

Why is it that Neah was so different from the other Noahs? Why did he want to kill them all and take the Earl's position unlike any of the others? He is indeed a very different noah and I can't wait untill Hoshino reveals that past.

[14thNoah]

I think after Allen killed Mana and he left with cross the earl came back and did some grave robbing and took Mana's body and put it on what I mean is if u guys seen men in black then u will understand

[KuzAnn]

Pfahahaha... I just had a funny thought...

What if the Earl tried to forcibly spawn more Noah by having kids? Dunno who he'd have them with, could be any woman since all humans carry the Noah gene, but suppose Neah ended up becoming the extra Noah while Mana stayed normal? Maybe that's why the Earl is so dang attached to Neah, being the "successful" son who turned into a Noah, while he didn't really care about Mana cause he turned out to be a normal human. The Earl being Mana and Neah's father could explain why Mana looks similar to him. What if the Earl was planning to get rid of Mana and that's what made Neah so mad that he tried to kill the Earl and take his place? Rhode did say that Neah fought for Mana... But of course, it's probably something much bigger than a father-son conflict. I'm just spewing out ideas that happen to float into my head here.

The similarity might just be coincidence and the fact that we don't get a good look at Mana's face though. Hmm... But if how he looks isn't significant to the plot then why keep hiding Mana's face? Hmmm...

Yeah I'm just rambling here. Take what you will.