theories and ideas

[InocenceExorcst]

So, I have been watching some clips that have had some significance in the series, such as Allen awakening the Crowned Clown, then him getting the sword. Then I had some thoughts about what could happen or the future of the series. The only people who would know what I am referring to have to really been keeping up with the series. Some suggestions are just badass to picture.

First, a sword fight between the Earl and Allen. We know it's coming. It's inevitable. But it is badass.

Next, I though of how the Earl had a sword like Allen's. I wondered how that happened. And something that fell into that was two things. First point is that Neah wants to become the Earl. Secondly, the Earl said he lost to the Heart loooong ago. How he lost was never referred to. Which made me wonder. What if the Earl was the owner of the Heart at first? What if he became the Earl, and the Heart saw this and fought back, killing him. All this is in speculation of if Allen is the owner of the Heart. If Allen is, a theory supporting the Earl was the first owner can be considered valid. This explains the sword as well, seeing as how the swords are the same. Through some unknown mean, maybe the Noah DNA in the Earl, he was able to use his power to copy an image of the sword. This would also set up a continuality thing, as Neah wants to become the Earl. If he were to be successful, the Heart would kill Allen, and Neah would be reborn as the Earl. When Allen awoke his full innocence against Tyki, Road saw Allen standing there, then she saw the Earl too. The sword could be a reminder, or something deeper.

One thing that is interesting is how Tyki (Joido) looks exactly like Neah. This apparently has a significant meaning, supported by how Tyki has taken such an interest in Allen and how they have met on different occasions and on each occasion, amazing things have happened (Crowned Clown sword was awoken by Tyki, Tyki destroyed Allen's innocence, Allen awake and enraged the Noah Tyki was suppressing).

Something else is how things have started reacting to Neah. Some people claim that when the Crowned Clown first awoke and he ripped up the akuma, it gave him the information because of it. It's not. The first is when he stabbed himself and the level 4 with his sword. The creepy face he gave and Noah's reaction was the first time the 14th actually surfaced. Before then, it was just his shadow. Neah has made a few appearances since then, including when Kanda stabbed him and even in direct combat with the Earl, even stating he will kill him and become the Earl. Another thing is Road. It is unknown if she is just playing around with Allen, although the kiss is reeeeeally playing around, although she could have genuine attraction to him, Neah could be influencing that by influencing that.

[snaccccans]

Next, I though of how the Earl had a sword like Allen's. I wondered how that happened. And something that fell into that was two things. First point is that Neah wants to become the Earl. Secondly, the Earl said he lost to the Heart loooong ago. How he lost was never referred to. Which made me wonder. What if the Earl was the owner of the Heart at first? What if he became the Earl, and the Heart saw this and fought back, killing him. All this is in speculation of if Allen is the owner of the Heart. If Allen is, a theory supporting the Earl was the first owner can be considered valid. This explains the sword as well, seeing as how the swords are the same. Through some unknown mean, maybe the Noah DNA in the Earl, he was able to use his power to copy an image of the sword. This would also set up a continuality thing, as Neah wants to become the Earl. If he were to be successful, the Heart would kill Allen, and Neah would be reborn as the Earl. When Allen awoke his full innocence against Tyki, Road saw Allen standing there, then she saw the Earl too. The sword could be a reminder, or something deeper.

Interesting. However you didnt expain much why Earl has the heart previously. I have a similar thoughts though. You were saying that Earl "copy" the sword he originally use to have, then why didnt he copy other weapons since the sword doesnt have much power if the sword just simply using his own power? In my opinion, the swords that both Allen and Earl uses have some form of connection in terms of the Noah's family background. What if the Earl had a normal innocence but turn it into another form which he could use to wield the sword. As you know that the "Earl Position" is what the 2 are after in which the Earl could be another human just like Allen and get his position by killing Neah? That would explain the sword that have its similaries as both came from innocence and their will to become Earl.

As you previously mention that Neah have not been fully awaken, Allen still show signs of Neah's will for instance the Musician Room that Allen use to control the ark. When he "pull out" his sword for the first time, he might have influence by Neah's will of becoming stronger in order to survive and defeat Earl. You might say that he have not shown any signs of Neah untill he control the ark (Neah's shadow), then how could Allen had invented the symbols (use for controlling the ark) with Mana? One might say is because Mana is the Neah's follower and that's why Allen came to know the symbols. However, why did Allen say they "invented" instead of Mana "taught" him? Maybe i'm going a bit too far, is just that I find it significant as it shows that Allen had some memories which belong to Neah as well as Neah's will. If that's the case, that would explain the swords wield by Allen and Earl because of similar will as well as they are from innocence.