a theory

[morno]

i just thout of somting here.. maybe allen was noah before mana cursed allen and he got the whigt hair.. he forgot who he was before he got cursed by mana.. maybe even mana was a noah?

[DeathHeiress88]

Yeah it is possible that Mana is a Noah...
*Spoiler*
In DGM reverse novel 3, it was said that Mana had golden eyes. So, it would be probably okay to say that he has a connection, if he's not entirely, to the noahs

[GoldenStar]

Nea, the 14th, is a Noah.
Mana and Nea are brothers.

[Skittlez]

I don't think that Allen would've forgotten who he was, unless a whole new past was created for him >.< A chapter in Reverse Novel 3 explains Allen's past from a while before he met Mana to shortly after he was adopted, and it explains a lot about his past :P ...Just not when the 14th first came into his life. Still, Allen was at the circus for a few years (I think) before he ever met Mana. So far Mana's been classified as human, and it would be unlikely for the story to go back on that and say that he's a Noah. In fact, one of the incentives for Neah to betray the Noah family was to protect Mana- his human brother.

Though, that theory sure is interesting :3 If it ended up happening, it would definitely bring up some interesting flashbacks... XD

[GoldenStar]

hey what if the part about Allen's parents is a lie? I've seem around the forum some stuff like this and was thinking 'How could any one know about Allen's past, before he even got into the circus ?'(read Reverse 3, if you don't know what I'm taking about)
I mean, even Allen himself didn't know, all he knew was that the circus bought him when he was young. Maybe, if the old ringmaster or Cosmo (XP) lived, we can figure out from one of them, but I don't think they got through that last performance. Cross doesn't know because he only knew about Allen after Mana met him. Are we even sure that Allen's parents even got rid of him? What if they kept him for bit before something happened ad they either died or had to give him up?
I don't know, honestly I think this would just make an interesting fanfiction, but hey anything's possible.

[hellyeah]

hey what if the part about Allen's parents is a lie? I've seem around the forum some stuff like this and was thinking 'How could any one know about Allen's past, before he even got into the circus ?'(read Reverse 3, if you don't know what I'm taking about)
I mean, even Allen himself didn't know, all he knew was that the circus bought him when he was young. Maybe, if the old ringmaster or Cosmo (XP) lived, we can figure out from one of them, but I don't think they got through that last performance. Cross doesn't know because he only knew about Allen after Mana met him. Are we even sure that Allen's parents even got rid of him? What if they kept him for bit before something happened ad they either died or had to give him up?
I don't know, honestly I think this would just make an interesting fanfiction, but hey anything's possible.

True.

Allen has no memories of his chilhood.

Now,I believe that Allen will become the 14 Noah,and there will be a new 15 Noah that will help Allen,and I believe that 15 Noah will be Allen brother.I get this idea from last chapter where it look like Allen has a brother.

[Skittlez]

I really hope that there wouldn't be a 15th Noah- it would seem like too much of a repeat, and it would most likely dilute interest in Neah. I think it would be better if Neah remained the sole phenomenon, now taking over Allen. Though I think it would be interesting if the Noah of Wrath reincarnated and something happened with that...

In the last chapter, I believe that was Neah, since he's the one that made up the Musician's Melody and in the page before the last it had a mother-like figure singing the lyrics to that song. However, it could easily be Mana. Either way, I think it will be interesting to find out what happens in the next chappy, though I'm sure that Hoshino will be mean and switch scenes to build the unnecessary suspense >.>

[hellyeah]

I really hope that there wouldn't be a 15th Noah- it would seem like too much of a repeat, and it would most likely dilute interest in Neah. I think it would be better if Neah remained the sole phenomenon, now taking over Allen. Though I think it would be interesting if the Noah of Wrath reincarnated and something happened with that...

In the last chapter, I believe that was Neah, since he's the one that made up the Musician's Melody and in the page before the last it had a mother-like figure singing the lyrics to that song. However, it could easily be Mana. Either way, I think it will be interesting to find out what happens in the next chappy, though I'm sure that Hoshino will be mean and switch scenes to build the unnecessary suspense >.>

Actually,I believe those memories belong to Allen,and that was Allen and his brother.

[Skittlez]

Except, if you look on page 31 (the second to last page), there is no disfigured arm on either of the twins. So far all we have to go off of about Allen's history before he was "adopted" into the circus is that he was born with his innocence, so one of the two kids should have his left arm if one of them were him. The kid on (our) left's arm shows no abnormal formations, while you can see the left hand of the child on the right in the panel before the last. This leads me to believe that neither of these kids are Allen. The kid on the next page can also be counted out as Allen both because of his age and once again, the hand. The age because that child looks older/as old as Allen when he was at the circus (and, like we all know, Allen was at the circus the entire time- he didn't have anyone to hold his hand out to for a lot of his youngest years), and there is, one again, the left hand without the inactive innocence.

Pages I used for reference:
31.jpg32.jpg

Your conclusion could still be possible, but at this moment through the progression of the series the more logical explanation is that those kids are Neah and Mana. You also have to take into account how the kid on the last page looks far more like Neah than Allen. I do think it would be interesting if Allen had a brother, though I'm just not convinced that those kids could be the two.

[hellyeah]

Except, if you look on page 31 (the second to last page), there is no disfigured arm on either of the twins. So far all we have to go off of about Allen's history before he was "adopted" into the circus is that he was born with his innocence, so one of the two kids should have his left arm if one of them were him. The kid on (our) left's arm shows no abnormal formations, while you can see the left hand of the child on the right in the panel before the last. This leads me to believe that neither of these kids are Allen. The kid on the next page can also be counted out as Allen both because of his age and once again, the hand. The age because that child looks older/as old as Allen when he was at the circus (and, like we all know, Allen was at the circus the entire time- he didn't have anyone to hold his hand out to for a lot of his youngest years), and there is, one again, the left hand without the inactive innocence.

Pages I used for reference:
Attachment 342Attachment 343

Your conclusion could still be possible, but at this moment through the progression of the series the more logical explanation is that those kids are Neah and Mana. You also have to take into account how the kid on the last page looks far more like Neah than Allen. I do think it would be interesting if Allen had a brother, though I'm just not convinced that those kids could be the two.

That the whole idea of Allen not having any memories of his early childhood.He said that he always had that red arm,but he really cannot remember his early childhood,so he really doesn't know.

This is the way the author can shift everything around,and change many things in the storyline.